my first boots

23
8:52 AM
A few days ago, I was pointed to a pattern on Etsy for some baby boots and I thought I'd give it at try. I plopped down my $4.50 and downloaded my PDF to get cracking. The results seem ok for the first go, but I don't think I could recommend this pattern unless you are very advanced at sewing and have a degree in puzzle solving and broken English. Harsh, but truthful.

I debated not posting about the boots at all for that reason, but I think they show off the versatility new Happy Camper prints quite well. Having no baby around, I grabbed a doxy to model. I just want to make sure I give an honest review before everyone forks over money for the pattern.






About the Pattern:
This pattern was designed by ithinksew.com and per it's policies, things made from this pattern can be sold. I found it to be a very challenging pattern to work with mostly because of grammatical errors and awkward pictures. (I realize I am a tad hypocritical as my blog is full of these problems, but I do not charge fees for viewing my blog.) As you can tell from the photos, I eventually worked out the directions but I think I would definitely tackle things differently next time.

Sizing: The pattern comes with templates for size 1 to 4 (0-12 months) The etsy store lists the size starting at 2, so size 1 is a bonus. I made the size 2 (3-6 months). I can't comment on pattern sizing as there is nothing in my house to compare it to. They look like they should fit a child about that age.

Templates: The pattern has clear non-overlapping templates. You must add seam allowance to them. Since they don't overlap and there's plenty of space, it would have been nice for seam allowance to be shown with a dotted line, but adding allowance is not hard and a tip is given to help.

Directions and Pictures: This is where I struggled. I found the directions unclear and the pictures didn't help much. In particular, I wish the directions were laid out in a more organized way with pictures along side each direction and more detail given instead of "See Pictures 2 & 5,6." Also, the pictures given are clearly from another pattern for shoes which is a bit confusing for the boots. The boot directions are tacked on at the end. The text seems cobbled from other patterns, as well, with a reference to a bag being given. The photos are marked up with directions on where to cut and sew, but I found it a bit like working out an advanced sudoku puzzle.

Modifications: Since this was my first go at baby boots, I tried to stick to the pattern. I used sewn in batting instead of fusible fleece. I think this is ok, but from the tip it was hard to tell. "After quilting, size will always be shrinking." Ummm. Yes. That cleared things up for me. Thanks for that.

I also added topstitching on the boot upper. If I were doing this pattern again, I would make serious modifications to the point that you probably wouldn't recognize my technique as the one given.

Pattern Notes: The boots close with velcro. I would suggest removing the decorative buttons if I were making this for young child.

About the Fabric:
Outer Shell - Happy Camper Plaid in Yellow by American Jane for Moda

Lining - Happy Camper Camp Basics in Navy by American Jane for Moda. Note: the Camp basics print comes with four different patterns on it. I used only a small bit of the checked section for the lining leaving me with three other prints and the typography stripes for another day!


So those are my first boots. I really wouldn't recommend this pattern. I suspect there are other patterns with similar results that are easier to use. I am vaguely happy with the results for the first go. With a few technique changes, I think I would have a tidier result. I don't see myself getting into the bootie business any time soon. You'll just see this same pair appearing again and again on random softies.

23 comments:

  1. Thanks for the honest pattern appraisal! I love the fabric you have used and although a difficult pattern...your results are great!

    ReplyDelete
  2. i agree. i appreciate the honest pattern review, and though it was hard, i think you did a great job. they are super cute!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Those are super cute. Sadly, I do not have a degree in broken English! ;-)

    ReplyDelete
  4. You crack me up Amy! I'm glad you struggled through and finished cause they're super cute boots. I especially enjoy your fabric choices. Perhaps you could create a new and improved pattern for us...with adult sizing too

    ReplyDelete
  5. such cute boots...what a pity they were such a pain in the rear to make! Thanks for posting an honest review.
    and check out Doxie rocking those boots! super cute.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thanks for the pattern review. It may be harsh but hey, it's true, and I would have gone out and bought this pattern on seeing your made booties but after reading your review, I've reconsidered because I am not the best with patterns to begin with! And don't need the stress. But... I do want booties like this - in my size of course! I wonder if you could size them up to adult sizes. Hmmm...

    Holly xx

    ReplyDelete
  7. I love the PDF pattern format and most I've bought have worked really well. However, like you, I was recently burned by one seller whose dress pattern would barely fit my little girl's doll, let alone fit her.

    I've struggled on whether to give bad feedback on etsy and whether to blog about it. Haven't done either so far. She offered a refund, but refuses to acknowledge that the pattern is flawed which, to me, seems the real problem.

    Sorry about the ramble, but your post just struck a cord.....

    ReplyDelete
  8. there's an extension market, doxie accessories......

    ReplyDelete
  9. I had purchased a pattern for baby mary janes from this seller and shared many of your frustrations. Your final product turned out loads better than mine!! I was fed up after the first that I didn't even attempt the second shoe. I had purchased the pattern because of the seller's 100% rating.... I am still confused about how so many others didn't find the pattern and directions as confusing and frustrating as I did.

    ReplyDelete
  10. These are so incredibly beautiful! I love them.

    Thanks for the warning about the tricky pattern. The boots actually look detailed enough that I would struggle even with a perfect pattern to work from. ;)

    Oh, these are lovely. I love the fabrics and the directions of the plaid and the buttons, and I love how the top of the boot overlaps the footie part. Superb!

    ReplyDelete
  11. Oh yes. I am so glad I wasn't the only one! I bought the shoe version of this pattern and was going out of my mind crazy with the whole "do not stitch 1/4 here" thing. I skipped the fusible fleece altogether and lined the shoe with some antipill fleece I had on hand. I almost don't want to leave feedback for this, becuase I don't want to hurt her feelings but damn! and just so you know, that is how baby sizes go :) infants to toddler start 1-10, then youth goes from 11-4. stupid right? lol . I made the 6-9 month size and it fits my 5 months old, I did not add the seam allowance before cutting though. I too didn't even attempt the other shoe because I was too pissed off.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I LOVE this seller's patterns, and found them exceptionally easy to follow. Every tiniest step is clearly explained and even accompanied by a photo. You really can't ask for more than that! Although her English is not perfect, it is easy to tell what she means to say, and anyway, I think the patterns are so beautifully illustrated that you could pretty much figure them out without any help from text at all! I'm sorry you had trouble with them, but I really don't think it's the fault of the patterns themselves, nor the seller. I was so thrilled with the unusually great patterns that I wish I could have left her some form of "double positive" in Etsy feedback!

    ReplyDelete
  13. "After quilting, size will always be shrinking," sounds to me pretty much like it is worded. If you choose to quilt the item, then you can expect the size to shrink with each wash, as commonly happens with quilted items. I'm not sure what else it even COULD mean, so I'm sorry to say I don't really understand why this was such an issue. This is a very nice seller with great customer service. Out of over 2,100 buyers, only 4 negatives.

    Most buyers praised the easy-to-follow instructions, and even one of the negatives (and a few of the positives) was a complaint that the instructions were TOO detailed for anyone who already knew how to sew!

    I feel so badly for this poor seller! She has a great line of patterns that almost all buyers found exceptionally easy to follow. I'd hate to think that potential buyers might be put off by what they read here, when the experience was so overwhelmingly positive for the vast majority of us!

    ReplyDelete
  14. ...sorry! "One of the NEUTRALS (and a few of the positives)" is what I meant to type!

    ReplyDelete
  15. Wee Sandy: Everyone has a right to an opinion and a right to post their experiences. I tried to email you after your first comment, but you left it anonymously. IMO, the pattern is not worth $4.50 USD. I could post several more examples of citing inadequate grammar and poor instructions in the boot pattern. I've left your comments here for others to see, as well. This way people can form a their own opinion and decide what they would like to do. With any online feedback system, you'll find a positive feedback bias, as people fear leaving negatives our of retribution.

    With close to $9000 under her belt, assuming there are 2000 happy people at $4.50 each, this seller could surely afford a pattern editor.

    ReplyDelete
  16. hey Wee Sandy.... is the seller also from toronto?

    I UNDERSTOOD THE:

    "After quilting, size will always be shrinking." Ummm. Yes. That cleared things up for me. Thanks for that"

    TO BE SARCASM...as in duh...hello...of COURSE..after quilting the size will shrink. you know sarcasm..like >... THANKS FOR THAT TIP..< (which obviously was an unnecessary tip; given that the rest of the instructions were hard to follow).

    Amy the fact that you left wee's comments on your blog - just shows yet another side of your honesty!!

    Thanks bundles and bushels for your your pattern review!! I agree...when selling... you've got to have it right!!

    thanks..
    xo
    eva

    ReplyDelete
  17. Hi! This comment is rather late in the game, but I wondered if you ever found a similar pattern to this one. I love the look of this boot and would really like to make it for my daughter, but I have NO interest in working through a complicated, frustrating pattern if there are better options out there.
    Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
  18. Hi, I recently got the pattern and I don't know if the pattern has changed since you worked on it but it's pretty easy to follow now. She has pictures of just one shoe/boot all along and there are tons of picture so you can't go wrong. Hope this helps other people who are still deciding if they should get the pattern or not.

    ReplyDelete
  19. I purchased this pattern a while ago and have not attempted it yet and now I'm nervous! I am not a super advanced sewer and I really want to make these for my new granddaughter so I will have to wing it and see how I do. Will let you know!

    ReplyDelete
  20. I too, purchased this pattern but have not attempted them yet and now I'm a wee bit nervous! I'm not a fantastic seamstress so I don't know how easy this is gonna be. I really want to make them for my new Granddaughter so I guess I'll have to give it a shot. Hopefully they don't turn out too horrible! Will let you know!

    ReplyDelete
  21. I've never understood why they make patterns that don't have the seam allowance included. Happened to me once and I never did complete the project. By the way your slippers are wicked cute!

    ReplyDelete
  22. Wee Sandy: Feel bad for her, not badly. Sorry. It's one of my irritations.

    ReplyDelete

You are a rockstar! Thanks so much for your comments!